Physics:Maxwell–Jüttner distribution

From HandWiki

In physics, the Maxwell–Jüttner distribution, sometimes called Jüttner–Synge distribution, is the distribution of speeds of particles in a hypothetical gas of relativistic particles. Similar to the Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution, the Maxwell–Jüttner distribution considers a classical ideal gas where the particles are dilute and do not significantly interact with each other. The distinction from Maxwell–Boltzmann's case is that effects of special relativity are taken into account. In the limit of low temperatures T much less than mc2/kB (where m is the mass of the kind of particle making up the gas, c is the speed of light and kB is Boltzmann constant), this distribution becomes identical to the Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution. The distribution can be attributed to Ferencz Jüttner, who derived it in 1911.[1] It has become known as the Maxwell–Jüttner distribution by analogy to the name Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution that is commonly used to refer to Maxwell's or Maxwellian distribution.

Definition

Maxwell–Jüttner distribution over Lorentz factor (relativistic Maxwell–Boltzmann), for a gas at different temperatures. Speed is represented in terms of the Lorentz factor.

As the gas becomes hotter and kBT approaches or exceeds mc2, the probability distribution for γ=1/1v2/c2 in this relativistic Maxwellian gas is given by the Maxwell–Jüttner distribution:[2]

f(γ)=γ2β(γ)θK2(1θ)eγ/θ

where β=vc=11/γ2, θ=kBTmc2, and K2 is the modified Bessel function of the second kind.

Alternatively, this can be written in terms of the momentum as f(𝐩)=14πm3c3θK2(1θ)eγ(p)θ where γ(p)=1+(pmc)2. The Maxwell–Jüttner equation is covariant, but not manifestly so, and the temperature of the gas does not vary with the gross speed of the gas.[3]

Jüttner distribution graph

A visual representation of the distribution in particle velocities for plasmas at four different temperatures:[4]

Where thermal parameter has been defined as μ=mc2kBT=1θ.

The four general limits are:

  • ultrarelativistic temperatures μ1θ1
  • relativistic temperatures: μ<1θ>1,
  • weakly (or mildly) relativistic temperatures: μ>1θ<1,
  • low temperatures: μ1θ1,

Limitations

Some limitations of the Maxwell–Jüttner distributions are shared with the classical ideal gas: neglect of interactions, and neglect of quantum effects. An additional limitation (not important in the classical ideal gas) is that the Maxwell–Jüttner distribution neglects antiparticles.

If particle-antiparticle creation is allowed, then once the thermal energy kBT is a significant fraction of mc2, particle-antiparticle creation will occur and begin to increase the number of particles while generating antiparticles (the number of particles is not conserved, but instead the conserved quantity is the difference between particle number and antiparticle number). The resulting thermal distribution will depend on the chemical potential relating to the conserved particle–antiparticle number difference. A further consequence of this is that it becomes necessary to incorporate statistical mechanics for indistinguishable particles, because the occupation probabilities for low kinetic energy states becomes of order unity. For fermions it is necessary to use Fermi–Dirac statistics and the result is analogous to the thermal generation of electron–hole pairs in semiconductors. For bosonic particles, it is necessary to use the Bose–Einstein statistics.[5]

Perhaps most significantly, the basic MB distribution has two main issues: it does not extend to particles moving at relativistic speeds, and  it assumes anisotropic temperature (where each DoF does not have the same translational kinetic energy).[clarification needed] While the classic Maxwell–Jüttner distribution generalizes for the case of special relativity, it fails to consider the anisotropic description.

Derivation

The Maxwell–Boltzmann (MB) distribution pdfMB describes the velocities 𝐮 or the kinetic energy ε=12m𝐮2 of the particles at thermal equilibrium, far from the limit of the speed of light, i.e:

pdfMB(𝐩;θ)=(πm2θ2)d/2e𝐩2/2mkBT

 

 

 

 

(1a)

θ2kBT/m,  uc

Or, in terms of the kinetic energy:

pdfMB(ε;T)=(kBT)d/2Γ(d2)eε/kBTε12d1

 

 

 

 

(1b)

εmc2

where θ is the temperature in speed dimensions, called thermal speed, and d denotes the kinetic degrees of freedom of each particle. (Note that the temperature is defined in the fluid’s rest frame, where the bulk speed 𝐮b is zero. In the non-relativistic case, this can be shown by using ε=12m(𝐮𝐮b)2.

The relativistic generalization of Eq. (1a), that is, the Maxwell–Jüttner (MJ) distribution, is given by:

pdfMJ(γ)γ2β(γ)eγθ,θkBTE0, E0=mc2

 

 

 

 

(2)

where β𝐮/c and γ(β)=(1β2)1/2. (Note that the inverse of the unitless temperature θ is the relativistic coldness ζ, Rezzola and Zanotti, 2013.) This distribution (Eq. 2) can be derived as follows. According to the relativistic formalism for the particle momentum and energy, one has

𝐩=mcγ(β)β, E(β)=γ(β)E0

 

 

 

 

(3)

While the kinetic energy is given by ε=EE0=(γ1)E0. The Boltzmann distribution of a Hamiltonian is pdfMJ(H)eHkBT. In the absence of a potential energy, H is simply given by the particle energy E, thus:

pdfMJ(E)eEkBTeγθ

 

 

 

 

(4a)

(Note that E is the sum of the kinetic ε and inertial energy E0,εkBT=γ 1θ). Then, when one includes the d-dimensional density of states:

pdfMJ(γ)p(γ)d1dp(γ)dγeγθ

 

 

 

 

(4b)

So that:

pdfMJ(𝐩)dp1dpdeE(𝐩)kBTdp1dpd=eE(γΩd)kBTdΩdpd1dp=ΩdeE(γΩd)kBT(p(γ)d1dp(γ)dγ)dΩddγ

Where dΩd denotes the d-dimensional solid angle. For isotropic distributions, one has

pdfMJ(p)dp1dpdeE(p)kBT(p(γ)d1dp(γ)dγ)dΩddγΩddΩdPMJ(γ)dγ

 

 

 

 

(5a)

or

pdfMJ(γ)eE(γ)kBTp(γ)d1dp(γ)dγ

 

 

 

 

(5b)

Then, d(γβ)=γ(γ21)12dγ=β1dγ so that:

p(γ)d1dp(γ)dγ=(mc)d(γβ)d1d(γβ)dγ=(mc)dγd1βd2,

 

 

 

 

(6)

Or:

pdfMJ(γ)γd1βd2eγθγ(γ21)d21eγθ

 

 

 

 

(7)

Now, because EkBT=γθ. Then, one normalises the distribution Eq. (7). One sets

pdfMJ(p,θ)dp1dpd=Neγ(p)/θdp1dpd

 

 

 

 

(8)

And the angular integration: dp1dpd=Bdpd1dp=12Bd(mc)d((pmc)2)d21d(pmc)2,

Where Bd=2πd/2Γ(d2) is the surface of the unit d-dimensional sphere. Then, using the identity γ2=(pmc)2+1 one has:

pdfMJ(𝐩;θ)dp1dpd=N12Bd(mc)deγθ(γ21)d21d(γ21).

 

 

 

 

(9)

and

1=pdfMJ(𝐩;θ)dp1dpd=N12Bd(mc)d1eγθ(γ21)d21d(γ21)=N12Bd(d2)1(mc)dθ11eγθ(γ21)d2dγ=N12Bd(d2)1(mc)dθ1Id,

 

 

 

 

(10)

Where one has defined the integral:

Id1eγ/θ(γ21)d/2dγ.

 

 

 

 

(11)

The Macdonald function (Modified Bessel function of the II kind) (Abramowitz and Stegun, 1972, p.376) is defined by:

Kn(z)π12(12z)nΓ(n+12)1ezγ(γ21)n12dγ

 

 

 

 

(12)

So that, by setting n=d+12, z=1θ one obtains:

Id=Γ(d2+1)π12Kd+12(1θ)(2θ)d+12

 

 

 

 

(13)

Hence,

N1=πd2Γ(d2)(d2)1Γ(d2+1)π12Kd+12(1θ)(mc)d(2θ)d+12=πd122d+12(mc)dθd12Kd+12(1θ),

 

 

 

 

(14a)

Or

N= π1d22d+12(mc)dθ1d2Kd+12(1θ)1,

 

 

 

 

(14b)

The inverse of the normalization constant gives the partition function Z1N:

Z=πd122d+12(mc)dθd12Kd+12(1θ),

 

 

 

 

(14c)

Therefore, the normalized distribution is:

pdfMJ(p;θ)dp1dpd=π1d22d+12(mc)dθ1d2Kd+12(1θ)1eγ(p)θdp1dpd

 

 

 

 

(15a)

Or one may derive the normalised distribution in terms of:

pdfMJ(γ;θ)dγ=π1221d2Γ(d2)Kd+12(1θ)1θ1d2eγθ(γ21)d21γdγ

 

 

 

 

(15b)

Note that θ can be shown to coincide with the thermodynamic definition of temperature.

Also useful is the expression of the distribution in the velocity space.[6] Given that d(βγ)dβ=γ3, one has:

dp1dpd=pd1dpdΩd=(mc)dγd1βd1d(βγ)dβdβdΩd=(mc)dγd+2βd1dβdΩd=(mc)dγd+2dβ1dβd

Hence

pdfMJ(β;θ)dβ1dβd=π1d22d+12θ1d2Kd+12(1θ)1eγ(β)θγ(β)d+2dβ1dβd

 

 

 

 

(15c)

Take d=3 (the “classic case” in our world):

pdfMJ(p;θ)dp1dpd=14π(mc)31θK2(1θ)1eγ(𝐩) θdp1dp2dp3

 

 

 

 

(16a)

And

pdfMJ(γ;θ)dγ=1θK2(1θ)1eγθ(γ21)12γdγ

 

 

 

 

(16b)

pdfMJ(β;θ)dβ1dβ2dβ3=4π1θK2(1θ)1eγ(β)θγ(β)5dβ1dβ2dβ3

 

 

 

 

(16c)

Note that when the MB distribution clearly deviates from the MJ distribution of the same temperature and dimensionality, one can misinterpret and deduce a different MBdistribution that will give a good approximation to the MJ distribution. This new MBdistribution can be either:

  • a convected MB distribution, that is, an MB distribution with the same dimensionality, but with different temperature TMB and bulk speed 𝐮b (or bulk energy Eb12m(𝐮+𝐮b)2)
  • an MB distribution with the same bulk speed, but with different temperature TMB and degrees of freedom dMB. These two types of approximations are illustrated.

Other properties

The MJ probability density function is given by:

pdfMJ(γ)=1θK2(1θ)γ2β(γ)eγ/θ

This means that a relativistic non-quantum particle with parameter θ has a probability of pdfMJ(γ)dγ of having its Lorentz factor in the interval [γ,γ+dγ].

The MJ cumulative distribution function is given by:

cdfMJ(γ)=1θK2(1θ)1γγ211γ2eγ/θdγ

That has a series expansion at γ=1:

cdfMJ(γ)=223e1/θθK2(1θ)γ13+152(5θ4)e1/θθ2K2(1θ)γ15+𝒪(γ17)

By definition limγcdfMJ(γ)=1, regardless of the parameter θ .

To find the average speed, vMJ , one must compute 1pdfMJ(γ)v(γ)dγ , where v(γ)=c11/γ2 is the speed in terms of its Lorentz factor. The integral simplifies to the closed- form expression:

vMJ=2cθ(θ+1)e1/θK2(1θ)

This closed formula for vMJ has a series expansion at θ=0:

1cvMJ=8πθ722πθ3+𝒪(θ5)

Or substituting the definition for the parameter θ : vMJ=8πkBTm722π1c2kBTm3+

Where the first term of the expansion, which is independently of c , corresponds to the average speed in the Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution, vMB=8πkBTm, whilst the following are relativistic corrections.

This closed formula for vMJ has a series expansion at θ=:

1cvMJ=1141θ2+𝒪(1θ3)

Or substituting the definition for the parameter θ:

vMJ=c14c5m2kB2T2+

Where it follows that c is an upper limit to the particle's speed, something only present in a relativistic context, and not in the Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution.

References

  1. Jüttner, F. (1911). "Das Maxwellsche Gesetz der Geschwindigkeitsverteilung in der Relativtheorie". Annalen der Physik 339 (5): 856–882. doi:10.1002/andp.19113390503. Bibcode1911AnP...339..856J. https://zenodo.org/record/1424205. 
  2. Synge, J.L (1957). The Relativistic Gas. Series in physics. North-Holland. 
  3. Chacon-Acosta, Guillermo; Dagdug, Leonardo; Morales-Tecotl, Hugo A. (2009). "On the Manifestly Covariant Jüttner Distribution and Equipartition Theorem". Physical Review E 81 (2 Pt 1): 021126. doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.81.021126. PMID 20365549. Bibcode2010PhRvE..81b1126C. 
  4. Lazar, M.; Stockem, A.; Schlickeiser, R. (2010-12-03). "Towards a Relativistically Correct Characterization of Counterstreaming Plasmas. I. Distribution Functions". The Open Plasma Physics Journal 3 (1). https://benthamopen.com/ABSTRACT/TOPPJ-3-138. 
  5. See first few paragraphs in [1] for extended discussion.
  6. Dunkel, Jörn; Talkner, Peter; Hänggi, Peter (2007-05-22). "Relative entropy, Haar measures and relativistic canonical velocity distributions". New Journal of Physics 9 (5): 144. doi:10.1088/1367-2630/9/5/144. ISSN 1367-2630. Bibcode2007NJPh....9..144D. https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1367-2630/9/5/144.