Pendulum (mechanics)

From HandWiki
Short description: Free swinging suspended body
Animation of a pendulum showing the velocity and acceleration vectors.

A pendulum is a body suspended from a fixed support so that it swings freely back and forth under the influence of gravity. When a pendulum is displaced sideways from its resting, equilibrium position, it is subject to a restoring force due to gravity that will accelerate it back towards the equilibrium position. When released, the restoring force acting on the pendulum's mass causes it to oscillate about the equilibrium position, swinging it back and forth. The mathematics of pendulums are in general quite complicated. Simplifying assumptions can be made, which in the case of a simple pendulum allow the equations of motion to be solved analytically for small-angle oscillations.

Simple gravity pendulum

A simple gravity pendulum[1] is an idealized mathematical model of a real pendulum.[2][3][4] This is a weight (or bob) on the end of a massless cord suspended from a pivot, without friction. Since in this model there is no frictional energy loss, when given an initial displacement it will swing back and forth at a constant amplitude. The model is based on these assumptions:

  • The rod or cord on which the bob swings is massless, inextensible and always remains taut.
  • The bob is a point mass.
  • Motion occurs only in two dimensions, i.e. the bob does not trace an ellipse but an arc.
  • The motion does not lose energy to friction or air resistance.
  • The gravitational field is uniform.
  • The support does not move.

The differential equation which represents the motion of a simple pendulum is

d2θdt2+gsinθ=0

 

 

 

 

(Eq. 1)

where g is the magnitude of the gravitational field, is the length of the rod or cord, and θ is the angle from the vertical to the pendulum.

Small-angle approximation

Small-angle approximation for the sine function: For θ ≈ 0 we find sin θθ.

The differential equation given above is not easily solved, and there is no solution that can be written in terms of elementary functions. However, adding a restriction to the size of the oscillation's amplitude gives a form whose solution can be easily obtained. If it is assumed that the angle is much less than 1 radian (often cited as less than 0.1 radians, about 6°), or θ1, then substituting for sin θ into Eq. 1 using the small-angle approximation, sinθθ, yields the equation for a harmonic oscillator, d2θdt2+gθ=0.

The error due to the approximation is of order θ3 (from the Taylor expansion for sin θ).

Let the starting angle be θ0. If it is assumed that the pendulum is released with zero angular velocity, the solution becomes

θ(t)=θ0cos(gt)θ01.

The motion is simple harmonic motion where θ0 is the amplitude of the oscillation (that is, the maximum angle between the rod of the pendulum and the vertical). The corresponding approximate period of the motion is then

T0=2πgθ01

which is known as Christiaan Huygens's law for the period. Note that under the small-angle approximation, the period is independent of the amplitude θ0; this is the property of isochronism that Galileo discovered.

Rule of thumb for pendulum length

T0=2πg gives =gπ2T024.

If SI units are used (i.e. measure in metres and seconds), and assuming the measurement is taking place on the Earth's surface, then g ≈ 9.81 m/s2, and g/π2 ≈ 1 m/s2 (0.994 is the approximation to 3 decimal places).

Therefore, relatively reasonable approximations for the length and period are: T024,T02 where T0 is the number of seconds between two beats (one beat for each side of the swing), and l is measured in metres.

Arbitrary-amplitude period

Figure 3. Deviation of the "true" period of a pendulum from the small-angle approximation of the period. "True" value was obtained numerically evaluating the elliptic integral.
Figure 4. Relative errors using the power series for the period.
Figure 5. Potential energy and phase portrait of a simple pendulum. Note that the x-axis, being angle, wraps onto itself after every 2π radians.

For amplitudes beyond the small angle approximation, one can compute the exact period by first inverting the equation for the angular velocity obtained from the energy method (Eq. 2), dtdθ=2g1cosθcosθ0 and then integrating over one complete cycle, T=t(θ00θ00θ0), or twice the half-cycle T=2t(θ00θ0), or four times the quarter-cycle T=4t(θ00), which leads to T=42g0θ0dθcosθcosθ0.

Note that this integral diverges as θ0 approaches the vertical limθ0πT=, so that a pendulum with just the right energy to go vertical will never actually get there. (Conversely, a pendulum close to its maximum can take an arbitrarily long time to fall down.)

This integral can be rewritten in terms of elliptic integrals as T=4gF(π2,sinθ02) where F is the incomplete elliptic integral of the first kind defined by F(φ,k)=0φdu1k2sin2u.

Or more concisely by the substitution sinu=sinθ2sinθ02 expressing θ in terms of u,

T=2T0πK(k),wherek=sinθ02. Eq. 3

Here K is the complete elliptic integral of the first kind defined by

K(k)=F(π2,k)=0π2du1k2sin2u.

For comparison of the approximation to the full solution, consider the period of a pendulum of length 1 m on Earth (g = 9.80665 m/s2) at initial angle 10 degrees is 41 mg K(sin102)2.0102 s. The linear approximation gives

2π1 mg2.0064 s.

The difference between the two values, less than 0.2%, is much less than that caused by the variation of g with geographical location.

From here there are many ways to proceed to calculate the elliptic integral.

Legendre polynomial solution for the elliptic integral

Given Eq. 3 and the Legendre polynomial solution for the elliptic integral: K(k)=π2n=0((2n1)!!(2n)!!kn)2 where n!! denotes the double factorial, an exact solution to the period of a simple pendulum is: T=2πg(1+(12)2sin2θ02+(1324)2sin4θ02+(135246)2sin6θ02+)=2πgn=0(((2n)!(2nn!)2)2sin2nθ02).

Figure 4 shows the relative errors using the power series. T0 is the linear approximation, and T2 to T10 include respectively the terms up to the 2nd to the 10th powers.

Power series solution for the elliptic integral

Another formulation of the above solution can be found if the following Maclaurin series: sinθ02=12θ0148θ03+13840θ051645120θ07+. is used in the Legendre polynomial solution above. The resulting power series is:[5]

T=2πg(1+116θ02+113072θ04+173737280θ06+229311321205760θ08+1319183951268147200θ010+2335264632009078326886400θ012+), more fractions available in the On-Line Encyclopedia of Integer Sequences with OEISA223067 having the numerators and OEISA223068 having the denominators.

Arithmetic-geometric mean solution for elliptic integral

Given Eq. 3 and the arithmetic–geometric mean solution of the elliptic integral: K(k)=π2M(1k,1+k), where M(x,y) is the arithmetic-geometric mean of x and y.

This yields an alternative and faster-converging formula for the period:[6][7][8] T=2πM(1,cosθ02)g.

The first iteration of this algorithm gives T1=2T01+cosθ02.

This approximation has the relative error of less than 1% for angles up to 96.11 degrees.[6] Since 12(1+cos(θ02))=cos2θ04, the expression can be written more concisely as T1=T0sec2θ04.

The second order expansion of sec2(θ0/4) reduces to TT0(1+θ0216).

A second iteration of this algorithm gives T2=4T01+cosθ02+2cosθ02=4T0(1+cosθ02)2.

This second approximation has a relative error of less than 1% for angles up to 163.10 degrees.[6]

Approximate formulae for the nonlinear pendulum period

Though the exact period T can be determined, for any finite amplitude θ0<π rad, by evaluating the corresponding complete elliptic integral K(k), where ksin(θ0/2), this is often avoided in applications because it is not possible to express this integral in a closed form in terms of elementary functions. This has made way for research on simple approximate formulae for the increase of the pendulum period with amplitude (useful in introductory physics labs, classical mechanics, electromagnetism, acoustics, electronics, superconductivity, etc.[9] The approximate formulae found by different authors can be classified as follows:

  • ‘Not so large-angle’ formulae, i.e. those yielding good estimates for amplitudes below π/2 rad (a natural limit for a bob on the end of a flexible string), though the deviation with respect to the exact period increases monotonically with amplitude, being unsuitable for amplitudes near to π rad. One of the simplest formulae found in literature is the following one by Lima (2006): TT0lna1a, where acos(θ0/2).[10]
  • ‘Very large-angle’ formulae, i.e. those which approximate the exact period asymptotically for amplitudes near to πrad, with an error that increases monotonically for smaller amplitudes (i.e., unsuitable for small amplitudes). One of the better such formulae is that by Cromer, namely:[11] T2πT0ln(4/a).

Of course, the increase of T with amplitude is more apparent when π/2<θ0<π, as has been observed in many experiments using either a rigid rod or a disc.[12] As accurate timers and sensors are currently available even in introductory physics labs, the experimental errors found in ‘very large-angle’ experiments are already small enough for a comparison with the exact period and a very good agreement between theory and experiments in which friction is negligible has been found. Since this activity has been encouraged by many instructors, a simple approximate formula for the pendulum period valid for all possible amplitudes, to which experimental data could be compared, was sought. In 2008, Lima derived a weighted-average formula with this characteristic:[9] Tra2TLima+k2TCromerra2+k2, where r=7.17, which presents a maximum error of only 0.6% (at θ0=95).

Arbitrary-amplitude angular displacement

The Fourier series expansion of θ(t) is given by[13][14]

θ(t)=8n1 odd(1)n/2nqn/21+qncos(nωt)

where q is the elliptic nome, q=exp(πK(1k2)/K(k)), k=sin(θ0/2), and ω=2π/T the angular frequency.

If one defines ε=121cos(θ0/2)1+cos(θ0/2) q can be approximated using the expansion q=ε+2ε5+15ε9+150ε13+1707ε17+20910ε21+ (see OEISA002103). Note that for θ0<π we have ε<12, thus the approximation is applicable even for large amplitudes.

Equivalently, the angle can be given in terms of the Jacobi elliptic function cd with modulus k[15] θ(t)=2arcsin(kcd(gt;k)),k=sinθ02.

For small x, sinxx, arcsinxx and cd(t;0)=cost, so the solution is well-approximated by the solution given in Pendulum (mechanics).

Examples

The animations below depict the motion of a simple (frictionless) pendulum with increasing amounts of initial displacement of the bob. The small graph above each pendulum is the corresponding phase plane diagram; the horizontal axis is displacement and the vertical axis is velocity.

Damped, driven pendulum

The above discussion focuses on a pendulum bob only acted upon by the force of gravity. Here we instead suppose a damping force, e.g. air resistance, as well as a sinusoidal driving force acts on the body. This system is a damped, driven oscillator, and is chaotic.

Equation (1) can be written as

ml2d2θdt2=mglsinθ

(see the Torque derivation of Equation (1) above).

We can now add a damping term and a forcing term to the right hand side to get

ml2d2θdt2=mglsinθbdθdt+acos(Ωt)

where we have assumed the damping couple to be proportional to the angular velocity (this is true for low-speed air resistance, see also Drag). a and b are constants defining the amplitude of forcing and the degree of damping respectively. Ω is the angular frequency of the driving oscillations.

We can now simplify by dividing through by ml2 and redefining the constants appropriately to obtain

d2θdt2+Bdθdt+glsinθ=Acos(Ωt).

This equation exhibits chaotic behaviour. The exact motion of this pendulum can only be found numerically and is highly dependent on initial conditions, e.g. the initial velocity and the starting amplitude. However, the small angle approximation outlined above can still be used under the required conditions to give an approximate analytical solution.

Compound pendulum

A compound pendulum (or physical pendulum) is one where the rod is not massless, and may have extended size; that is, an arbitrarily shaped rigid body swinging by a pivot O. In this case the pendulum's period depends on its moment of inertia IO around the pivot point.

The equation of torque gives: τ=Iα where: α is the angular acceleration. τ is the torque

The torque is generated by gravity so: τ=mgrCMsinθ where:

  • m is the total mass of the ridig body (rod and bob)
  • rCM is the distance from the pivot point to the system's center of mass
  • θ is the angle from the vertical

Hence, under the small-angle approximation, sinθθ, α=θ¨mgrCMIOθ where IO is the moment of inertia of the body about the pivot point O.

The expression for α is of the same form as the conventional simple pendulum and gives a period of[2] T=2πIOmgrCM

And a frequency of f=1T=12πmgrCMIO

If the initial angle is taken into consideration (for large amplitudes), then the expression for α becomes: α=θ¨=mgrCMIOsinθ and gives a period of: T=4K(sin2θmax2)IOmgrCM where θmax is the maximum angle of oscillation (with respect to the vertical) and K(k) is the complete elliptic integral of the first kind.

An important concept is the equivalent length, eq, the length of a simple pendulums that has the same angular frequency ω0 as the compound pendulum: ω02=geq=mgrCMIOeq=IOgrCM

Consider the following cases:

  • The simple pendulum is the special case where all the mass is located at the bob swinging at a distance from the pivot. Thus, rCM= and IO=m2, so the expression reduces to: ω02=mgrCMIO=mgm2=g . Notice eq=, as expected (the definition of equivalent length).
  • A homogeneous rod of mass m and length swinging from its end has rCM=12 and IO=13m2, so the expression reduces to: ω02=mgrCMIO=mg1213m2=g23 . Notice eq=23, a homogeneous rod oscilates as if it were a simple pendulum of two-thirds its length.
  • A heavy simple pendulum: combination of a homogeneous rod of mass mrod and length swinging from its end, and a bob mbob at the other end. Then the system has a total mass of mbob+mrod, and the other parameters being rCM=mbob+mrodmbob+2mrod and IO=mbob2+13mrod2, so the expression reduces to:

ω02=mgrCMIO=(mbob+mrod)gmbob+mrodmbob+2mrodmbob2+13mrod2=g(mbob+mrod)2(mbob+2mrod)(mbob+13mrod)=g(1+mrodmbob)2(1+2mrodmbob)(1+13mrodmbob). Notice this formula can be particularized into the two previous cases studied before just by considering the mass of the rod or the bob to be zero respectively. Also notice that the formula does not depend on both the mass of the bob and the rod, but on their ratio, mrodmbob. An approximation can be made for mrodmbob1: ω02g11+13mrodmbobg(113mrodmbob+)

Notice how similar it is to the angular frecuency in a spring-mass system with effective mass, and how Rayleigh's value apears.

Physical interpretation of the imaginary period

The Jacobian elliptic function that expresses the position of a pendulum as a function of time is a doubly periodic function with a real period and an imaginary period. The real period is, of course, the time it takes the pendulum to go through one full cycle. Paul Appell pointed out a physical interpretation of the imaginary period:[16] if θ0 is the maximum angle of one pendulum and 180° − θ0 is the maximum angle of another, then the real period of each is the magnitude of the imaginary period of the other.

Coupled pendula

Two identical simple pendulums coupled via a spring connecting the bobs.

Coupled pendulums can affect each other's motion, either through a direction connection (such as a spring connecting the bobs) or through motions in a supporting structure (such as a tabletop). The equations of motion for two identical simple pendulums coupled by a spring connecting the bobs can be obtained using Lagrangian mechanics.

The kinetic energy of the system is: EK=12mL2(θ˙12+θ˙22) where m is the mass of the bobs, L is the length of the strings, and θ1, θ2 are the angular displacements of the two bobs from equilibrium.

The potential energy of the system is: Ep=mgL(2cosθ1cosθ2)+12kL2(θ2θ1)2

where g is the gravitational acceleration, and k is the spring constant. The displacement L(θ2θ1) of the spring from its equilibrium position assumes the small angle approximation.

The Lagrangian is then =12mL2(θ˙12+θ˙22)mgL(2cosθ1cosθ2)12kL2(θ2θ1)2 which leads to the following set of coupled differential equations: θ¨1+gLsinθ1+km(θ1θ2)=0θ¨2+gLsinθ2km(θ1θ2)=0

Adding and subtracting these two equations in turn, and applying the small angle approximation, gives two harmonic oscillator equations in the variables θ1+θ2 and θ1θ2: θ¨1+θ¨2+gL(θ1+θ2)=0θ¨1θ¨2+(gL+2km)(θ1θ2)=0 with the corresponding solutions θ1+θ2=Acos(ω1t+α)θ1θ2=Bcos(ω2t+β) where ω1=gLω2=gL+2km

and A, B, α, β are constants of integration.

Expressing the solutions in terms of θ1 and θ2 alone: θ1=12Acos(ω1t+α)+12Bcos(ω2t+β)θ2=12Acos(ω1t+α)12Bcos(ω2t+β)

If the bobs are not given an initial push, then the condition θ˙1(0)=θ˙2(0)=0 requires α=β=0, which gives (after some rearranging): A=θ1(0)+θ2(0)B=θ1(0)θ2(0)

See also

References

  1. defined by Christiaan Huygens: Huygens, Christian (1673). "Horologium Oscillatorium". 17thcenturymaths.com. http://www.17centurymaths.com/contents/huygens/horologiumpart4a.pdf. , Part 4, Definition 3, translated July 2007 by Ian Bruce
  2. 2.0 2.1 Nave, Carl R. (2006). "Simple pendulum". Georgia State Univ.. http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/pend.html. 
  3. Xue, Linwei (2007). "Pendulum Systems". Civil Engineering Dept., Univ. of Manchester, UK. http://www.mace.manchester.ac.uk/project/teaching/civil/structuralconcepts/Dynamics/pendulum/pendulum_con.php. 
  4. Weisstein, Eric W. (2007). "Simple Pendulum". Wolfram Research. http://scienceworld.wolfram.com/physics/SimplePendulum.html. 
  5. Nelson, Robert; Olsson, M. G. (February 1986). "The pendulum — Rich physics from a simple system". American Journal of Physics 54 (2): 112–121. doi:10.1119/1.14703. Bibcode1986AmJPh..54..112N. 
  6. 6.0 6.1 6.2 Carvalhaes, Claudio G.; Suppes, Patrick (December 2008), "Approximations for the period of the simple pendulum based on the arithmetic-geometric mean", Am. J. Phys. 76 (12͒): 1150–1154, doi:10.1119/1.2968864, ISSN 0002-9505, Bibcode2008AmJPh..76.1150C, https://suppes-corpus.stanford.edu/sites/g/files/sbiybj7316/f/approximations_for_the_period_of_the_simple_pendulum_based_on_the_arithmetic-geometric_mean_431.pdf, retrieved 2013-12-14 
  7. Borwein, J.M.; Borwein, P.B. (1987). Pi and the AGM. New York: Wiley. pp. 1–15. ISBN 0-471-83138-7. 
  8. Van Baak, Tom (November 2013). "A New and Wonderful Pendulum Period Equation". Horological Science Newsletter 2013 (5): 22–30. http://www.leapsecond.com/hsn2006/pendulum-period-agm.pdf. 
  9. 9.0 9.1 Lima, F. M. S. (2008-09-10). "Simple 'log formulae' for pendulum motion valid for any amplitude". European Journal of Physics 29 (5): 1091–1098. doi:10.1088/0143-0807/29/5/021. ISSN 0143-0807. http://stacks.iop.org/0143-0807/29/i=5/a=021?key=crossref.78b07aabf445ee2e2934f76c20a9cff4. 
  10. Lima, F. M. S.; Arun, P. (October 2006). "An accurate formula for the period of a simple pendulum oscillating beyond the small angle regime". American Journal of Physics 74 (10): 892–895. doi:10.1119/1.2215616. ISSN 0002-9505. Bibcode2006AmJPh..74..892L. 
  11. Cromer, Alan (February 1995). "Many oscillations of a rigid rod". American Journal of Physics 63 (2): 112–121. doi:10.1119/1.17966. ISSN 0002-9505. Bibcode1995AmJPh..63..112C. 
  12. Gil, Salvador; Legarreta, Andrés E.; Di Gregorio, Daniel E. (September 2008). "Measuring anharmonicity in a large amplitude pendulum". American Journal of Physics 76 (9): 843–847. doi:10.1119/1.2908184. ISSN 0002-9505. Bibcode2008AmJPh..76..843G. 
  13. Lawden, Derek F. (1989). Elliptic Functions and Applications. Springer-Verlag. p. 40. ISBN 0-387-96965-9.  Eq. 2.7.9: kksdudu=arcsin(kcdu)+C
  14. Reinhardt, W. P.; Walker, P. L. (2010), "Jacobian Elliptic Functions", in Olver, Frank W. J.; Lozier, Daniel M.; Boisvert, Ronald F. et al., NIST Handbook of Mathematical Functions, Cambridge University Press, ISBN 978-0-521-19225-5, http://dlmf.nist.gov/22.11.E5 
  15. "A Complete Solution to the Non-Linear Pendulum". 4 December 2021. https://medium.com/physicsfromscratch/a-complete-solution-to-the-non-linear-pendulum-9afda0b64926. 
  16. Appell, Paul (July 1878). "Sur une interprétation des valeurs imaginaires du temps en Mécanique". Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances de l'Académie des Sciences 87 (1). 

Further reading